Supreme Court Overturns Half of HACC Rulings Involving Judge Glotov: Study
A new legal study reveals that the Supreme Court canceled 23 out of 46 reviewed decisions issued by the HACC Appeals Chamber where Mykola Glotov served as the rapporteur judge.
Photo: unian.ua
Key points
- Supreme Court overturned 23 of 46 HACC rulings involving Judge Glotov
- Most reversals targeted procedural issues and returned complaints
- Experts recommend expanding cassation review for third-party property rulings
The civil organization "Правова держава" ("Rule of Law") has published a comprehensive analysis of judicial practice covering the period from March 2020 to October 2026. The study focused on the performance of Mykola Glotov, a judge of the High Anti-Corruption Court's Appeals Chamber, whose rulings frequently underwent cassation review. In total, the researchers examined 207 Supreme Court rulings related to HACC cases.
Details of Overturned Rulings and Procedural Nuances
According to the published data, the Supreme Court overturned exactly half of the 46 decisions where Glotov acted as the rapporteur judge, totaling 23 rulings. Notably, these cases account for nearly 29% of all overturned decisions within the analyzed sample of HACC practice. The vast majority of these reversals concerned procedural matters rather than the merits of the allegations.
Specifically, 20 out of the 23 canceled rulings involved participants' procedural rights and access to justice. The largest share comprised decisions on returning appellate complaints or motions, with the cassation court overturning 14 out of 19 reviewed rulings of this type. The authors also highlight existing legal restrictions, as the current Criminal Procedure Code prohibits cassation review of certain lower-court rulings regarding asset seizures or pre-trial detention.
The statistical data only covers cases that reached the Supreme Court level, rather than the entire scope of the judge's practice.
In addition to statistics, the study reviewed Glotov's dissenting opinions on evidence admissibility and renewal of appeal deadlines for property owners. Experts suggest discussing the expansion of cassation access for rulings affecting third-party property.
Source unian.ua — unian.ua/society/verhovniy-sud-skasuvav-polovinu-pereglyanutih-rish… ↗
Read next
Saving a Water-Damaged Smartphone: 4 Mistakes to Avoid
Experts debunk common myths about drying gadgets and offer professional advice to prevent costly repairs.
EU spent more on Russian energy than on aid to Ukraine, European Commission data shows
Since 2022, EU member states have paid Russia more for energy imports than the total financial support provided to Ukraine.
🏢БізнесSpaceX hires Washington lobbyists ahead of potential US Congressional probes
Elon Musk's aerospace company has engaged professional lobbyists to navigate upcoming Congressional scrutiny regarding Starlink operations in Ukraine.
🏢БізнесStrikes on the Crimean Bridge: Economic Impact on Logistics and Shipping
Damage to the Crimean Bridge by Ukrainian missiles creates significant logistical hurdles for the Russian Federation and disrupts maritime trade.
🏢БізнесEU to Provide €1 Billion for Military Equipment for Ukraine
The Council of the European Union has approved a new military aid package via the European Peace Facility to strengthen Ukraine's defense capabilities.
🏢БізнесRussian strike destroys Fresh Production Group's film studio
On the night of November 20, a Russian attack completely destroyed the filming studio of a prominent Ukrainian production company. No casualties were reported.