LIVE
Saving a Water-Damaged Smartphone: 4 Mistakes to Avoid EU spent more on Russian energy than on aid to Ukraine, European Commission data shows SpaceX hires Washington lobbyists ahead of potential US Congressional probes Geopolitical summit in China: expert assessment of the meeting between US, Chinese, and Russian leaders Strikes on the Crimean Bridge: Economic Impact on Logistics and Shipping EU to Provide €1 Billion for Military Equipment for Ukraine Technological Superiority and the Crimean Bridge: Expert Analysis Zelenskyy Reaffirms Legitimacy of Strikes on Crimean Bridge Russian strike destroys Fresh Production Group's film studio Energy infrastructure in Rivne region damaged by attack: 50 settlements left without power Saving a Water-Damaged Smartphone: 4 Mistakes to Avoid EU spent more on Russian energy than on aid to Ukraine, European Commission data shows SpaceX hires Washington lobbyists ahead of potential US Congressional probes Geopolitical summit in China: expert assessment of the meeting between US, Chinese, and Russian leaders Strikes on the Crimean Bridge: Economic Impact on Logistics and Shipping EU to Provide €1 Billion for Military Equipment for Ukraine Technological Superiority and the Crimean Bridge: Expert Analysis Zelenskyy Reaffirms Legitimacy of Strikes on Crimean Bridge Russian strike destroys Fresh Production Group's film studio Energy infrastructure in Rivne region damaged by attack: 50 settlements left without power

The «NATO in exchange for Donbas» proposal is unfeasible due to Alliance procedures — NISS

🧠 AI Analysis 2 min read 👁 3

Proposals for Ukraine's NATO membership in exchange for eastern territories lack practical implementation mechanisms due to the required consensus among all 32 member states.

The «NATO in exchange for Donbas» proposal is unfeasible due to Alliance procedures — NISS🧠AI Analysis

Photo: 24tv.ua

Key points

  • Trading territories for NATO membership lacks realistic enforcement mechanisms.
  • Approval requires unanimous consent from all 32 Alliance parliaments.
  • Kyiv maintains its strict policy against recognizing any territorial losses.

Discussions regarding Ukraine potentially joining the North Atlantic Alliance in exchange for giving up eastern regions are practically unfeasible. This was stated by Ivan Us, chief consultant at the National Institute for Strategic Studies, during a broadcast on Channel 24.

According to the expert, individual American negotiators lack the authority to make decisions on behalf of all 32 member nations. Approving such a step requires the consent of the parliaments of every single ally, including nations with skeptical positions such as Slovakia. The specialist emphasized:

«Speaking of Ukraine being in NATO in exchange for territories is essentially promising something you cannot deliver».

The analyst also highlighted contradictory signals coming from American politicians, pointing to previous statements by Vice President JD Vance regarding Kyiv's membership prospects. In the expert's view, the underlying objective of such initiatives is an attempt to persuade Ukraine to officially renounce its lands, while the actual integration process could subsequently drag on for decades.

As an example of strategic resilience, the analyst cited Azerbaijan, which refused to recognize the occupation of Karabakh for 30 years and eventually restored control over those territories. Furthermore, serious internal resolve issues persist within NATO itself, as evidenced by statements from Slovak Prime Minister Robert Fico regarding allied defense commitments.

Source 24tv.ua — 24tv.ua/nato-obmin-donbas-analitik-poyasniv-chomu-tsya-propozitsiya-ye_… ↗

Contact the newsroom

Got a tip, a proposal or a partnership question? Write to us and we will reply shortly.