MoD and GPS tracking: is monitoring conscripts via smartphones legal?
Legal experts have clarified that implementing hidden geolocation tracking for conscripts via state mobile applications is legally impossible and violates the Constitution.
🧾Податки та виплатиPhoto: 24tv.ua
Key points
- GPS tracking via apps is illegal
- Oberih registry uses only official data
- Reform aims to eliminate errors in military records
The Ministry of Defense of Ukraine is working on streamlining the military registration system through the 'Oberih' registry. Amid these efforts, concerns have arisen regarding the potential use of smartphone geolocation data to monitor the movement of citizens. However, experts emphasize that such methods lack any legal basis.
Legal boundaries of monitoring
Lawyer Viktoriia Drapailo explained that constant geolocation tracking via civilian applications, such as 'Diia' or 'Rezerv+', would be a direct violation of the Constitution and international law. She noted, "Constant monitoring of movements is a serious interference with a person's private life." Under Ukrainian law, electronic surveillance is only permitted in criminal proceedings and requires a court order.
Currently, the 'Oberih' registry receives data through inter-agency exchanges, including information on employment, registered residence, and border crossing data. However, this information only indicates a person's probable location rather than their precise real-time coordinates.
The primary goal of the reform is to eliminate errors in the distribution of draft notices. Automating data exchange is intended to prevent situations where citizens who have already updated their information or are legally abroad receive incorrect notices, thereby reducing the burden on the judicial system and saving citizens from unnecessary legal expenses.
Source 24tv.ua — 24tv.ua/zmini-viyskovomu-obliku-yak-derzhava-shukatime-viyskovozobovyaz… ↗
Read next
Saving a Water-Damaged Smartphone: 4 Mistakes to Avoid
Experts debunk common myths about drying gadgets and offer professional advice to prevent costly repairs.
EU spent more on Russian energy than on aid to Ukraine, European Commission data shows
Since 2022, EU member states have paid Russia more for energy imports than the total financial support provided to Ukraine.
🏢БізнесSpaceX hires Washington lobbyists ahead of potential US Congressional probes
Elon Musk's aerospace company has engaged professional lobbyists to navigate upcoming Congressional scrutiny regarding Starlink operations in Ukraine.
🧠AI AnalysisGeopolitical summit in China: expert assessment of the meeting between US, Chinese, and Russian leaders
Political scientist Ramiz Yunus analyzed the summit in Shenzhen, describing it as a media-driven event rather than a strategic diplomatic breakthrough.
🏢БізнесStrikes on the Crimean Bridge: Economic Impact on Logistics and Shipping
Damage to the Crimean Bridge by Ukrainian missiles creates significant logistical hurdles for the Russian Federation and disrupts maritime trade.
🏢БізнесEU to Provide €1 Billion for Military Equipment for Ukraine
The Council of the European Union has approved a new military aid package via the European Peace Facility to strengthen Ukraine's defense capabilities.